Wines & Vines

December 2018 Collectors Edition

Issue link: http://winesandvines.uberflip.com/i/1065812

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 71 of 147

72 WINES&VINES Collector's Edition S ustainable wine-grape growing is a journey, not a destination. In the next few para- graphs, I will make the case for why using this approach for growing wine grapes is so important. I will then discuss some signifi- cant areas of tension in the wine industry that have come about as the sustainability movement has evolved, which may help growers better negotiate them Sustainable grapegrowing as an overarching approach There are three basic approaches to growing wine grapes: conventional, organic and biodynamic. I contend that all three fit under the umbrella of sustainable wine grapegrowing. The three approaches have certain characteristics in common. All use labor and energy as inputs. They all re- quire land clearance to establish a vineyard. Practitioners of each type are proud of the way they farm and feel it is the best way to farm. And they all have resulted in grapes that were made into award-winning wines as well as forget- table ones. Furthermore, all three approaches recognize the importance of healthy soil for a successful farm. The three approaches differ significantly as well. Con- ventional viticulture involves the use of both synthetic and naturally derived soil amendments, nutrients and pesti- cides. Organic and biodynamic viticulture prohibit the use of any synthetic nutrients or pesticides, and both require soil building through addition of organic matter, using practices like cover cropping and compost additions. Bio- dynamic farming differs from the other two in requiring practices and inputs outlined by Rudolf Steiner in a series of eight lectures in 1924. For example, a grower must use nine plant-derived "preparations" in crop management. Most are added to the composting process, and the others are mixed with water and sprayed onto the crops. Animals must also be a part of the farming op- eration. There are other practices that make biodynamic farming unique, but space does not allow a more detailed discussion. It is worth noting that biodynamic and or- ganic farming were developed in the 1920s, '30s and '40s, when some farmers and farming advocates were becoming very concerned about the negative impacts of off-farm inputs, such as synthetic fertilizers and pesticides, and the decline in soil health as a result. Organic and biodynamic certifica- tion programs fully addressed these concerns through specific farming practice requirements and prohibition of synthetic inputs. During the last 20 years, other important issues besides the negative impacts of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides came to our attention, such as energy use, water use, farm biodiversity, climate change and worker welfare and safety. All of which have been addressed by sustainable agriculture through the promotion of practices designed to optimize the use of energy and water, improve worker welfare and safety, and enhance farm biodiversity. Many sustainable-farming certification programs have been established in the last 20 years and address most, if not all, of these issues through specific farming practice standards. While organic and biodynamic farmers would likely agree that these more recent issues are very important and must be addressed, their respective certification pro- grams have not yet incorporated practices to do so. Profits and sustainable growing We farm in a capitalistic system and, therefore, unless a vineyard owner has a second income besides the vineyard, wine-grape growing must ultimately produce a profit for it to be sustainable. The cost of producing wine grapes varies tremendously based on location and the farming practices used. The revenue from a vineyard also varies tremendously based on location, yield and perception of the quality of the wine produced. Therefore, the cost of production for a given vineyard compared to the price per ton of grapes in the winery contract will determine to what degree sustain- able farming practices can be used, such as cover cropping, compost addition, organic versus synthetic fertilizer, pesti- cide choice, mowing versus sheep grazing, management of hedgerows for biodiversity, and so forth. I once visited a Syrah vineyard where half went to one winery and the other half to another, each paying a different price per ton. More sustainable practices were being used on the section receiv- ing the higher price. Sustainable growing and pesticides As with any human endeavor where there is more than one approach to accomplish something, there are advocates and critics of each one. Farming is no exception. Advocacy and criticism are based on a range of things, such as re- search results, environmental activism, experience, ideology or a combination of all of them. In my experience, pesticide use is the most controversial topic among farmers, farming advocates, environmentalists, ag input supply companies and the public. Vineyard View n CLIFF OHMART What is Sustainable Wine Grapegrowing

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of Wines & Vines - December 2018 Collectors Edition