Issue link: http://winesandvines.uberflip.com/i/1065812
68 WINES&VINES Collector's Edition Here's What Works O ver the last three years, I've been fortu- nate to write 17 columns for Wines & Vines. The line "Here's What Works" was deliberate, focusing on the needs of a reader who runs a small vineyard or winery, fewer than 25,000 cases, and located outside the Napa/Sonoma vortex of excellent, well-established brands (as well as a few wealthy wan- nabes who thought building a winery would make a better "personal shrine" than would a yacht or thorough- bred horses). I interviewed people just like you, and asked them how they incorporate new technologies and best practices into their operations, so that you could learn from their first-hand experience. After three years of writing, and more than 30 years in this industry, these are my nine most valuable observations: 1 Differentiate or die. Avoid the mantra of "This is how it's done in the wine industry." Blue Ocean Strategy, developed by W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne, observes, "Today's overcrowded in- dustries competing head-on results in nothing but a bloody red ocean of rivals fighting over a shrinking profit pool. Lasting success comes, not from battling competitors, but from creating blue oceans of untapped new mar- ket spaces ripe for growth." My colleague John Stallcup is more blunt: "Differentiate or die." Yet many wineries all too often follow the satirical quote found on Despair.com: "Conformity: When people are free to do as they please, they usually imitate each other." So many winery websites' "About Us" pages note that they are family operations dedicated to quality and sustainability, that their wines are made in the vineyard. Their b a c k l a b e l s u n i f o r m l y note that their Chardon- nay goes well with chicken, and Zinfandel with Italian food. All noble attributes. All well-written. And all the same. Wine is an industry where few want to lead, but everyone wants to be the first to be second. Common wisdom states that you must revere tradition and do things the way the wine industry does it. Yet so many successful brands did just the opposite. Chardonnay "must" be dry, yet Jackson Family Wines made its fortune producing an off-dry version that consumers love and detractors still say was made "incorrectly." You must use French varieties, yet Bokisch Vineyards in Lodi, Calif., successfully specializes in Iberian varietals. The owner has roots in Catalonia, so their story is authentic and unique. Quady, a boutique winery in California's Central Valley, thrives because it's the only winery specializing in sweet vinifera wines. Don't let tradition be a barrier to free thinking. 2 Business planning is good. It could be that when you hear the phrase "business plan," the first thing you think of is your previous career working at a soul-sucking large corporation. Yet establishing and reviewing a business plan will make your winery more successful, prevent you from un- expectedly running out of cash, and keep your banker and shareholders happy. Holly Finkel- stein, an owner of Judd's Hill, a small Napa Valley winery, provided a great example. She works from both a one-year plan and a five- year plan that sets bigger goals, production, profitability levels and capital needs. Finkel- stein includes the entire management team in a collaborative process. Jason Hinde at Exchange Bank explained to me that without a business plan, you may be relying upon a "Field of Dreams" strategy of building it (bottling wines) and hoping Shoeless Joe Jackson (the c o n s u m e r ) w i l l a p p e a r. While it is a beautiful story, it's also fictional. n ANDY STARR The Top Nine Lessons Learned on What Works in the Wine Industry

